Media Releases and Opportunities

Transgender, nonbinary and gender-diverse people face barriers in accessing both surgery and the health system in general, according to two new research papers published in the CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal). 

In many areas of life, people who identify as transgender, nonbinary and gender diverse experience discrimination even where there are laws to protect transgender human rights. Health systems also pose barriers for transgender, nonbinary and gender-diverse people, who are more likely to delay obtaining medical care because of fear of discrimination and other factors. 

In a new research article, authors describe the experiences of transgender, nonbinary and gender-diverse people in accessing gender-affirming surgery. A related humanities article argues that gender self-determination is a medical right. 

As there are few Canadian studies on the surgical experiences of people who self-identify as members of these populations, authors sought to understand their experiences when seeking gender-affirming care. Participants reported barriers in accessing this care, which also affected their general experiences with the health-care system. 

"The stress of negotiating presurgical bureaucracy often stood in sharp contrast to the positive feelings [participants] experienced when deciding to seek gender-affirming surgery," writes co-author Dr. Hilary MacCormick, an anesthesiologist in the Department of Women's and Obstetric Anesthesia, IWK Health, and assistant professor at Dalhousie University. "Participants described the need to self-advocate when interacting with health care professionals who had a lack of experience with or negative attitude toward [transgender or nonbinary] people."

VIEW ARTICLE

These barriers and marginalization can cause additional trauma in a situation where patients of any background might feel stress and anxiety because of surgery. 

"Our data support the need for more in-depth and nuanced discussions surrounding shared decision-making and consideration of potential effects of past traumas, instances of invalidation, or negative interactions within health care," the authors conclude.

The findings of the study on the lived experiences of people seeking publicly funded penile-inversion vaginoplasty were similar. "Health-care systems need to improve access to gender-affirmation surgery, reduce wait times for care by increasing capacity for gender-affirmation surgery and improve care experiences," writes Dr. Gianni Lorello, a scientist at the Women's College Research and Innovation Institute, anesthesiologist at University Health Network, and associate professor at the University of Toronto.

In a related humanities article, Florence Ashley, assistant professor, Faculty of Law and John Dossetor Health Ethics Centre at the University of Alberta, argues that gender self-determination is a medical right and that health-care providers are ethically bound to respect this. 

"The burden of justifying barriers to care should fall on the health-care providers who erect them and not on those seeking care to affirm their gender," Ashley argues.

"Health-care providers working with transgender communities should carefully examine their gatekeeping practices to ascertain whether they are justified by clear and compelling evidence and abandon those that cannot meet this justificatory threshold."

Dr. Kirsten Patrick, editor-in-chief of CMAJ, comments in an editorial that, "receiving care that validates their chosen identity is associated with better physical and mental health for transgender and gender-diverse patients. Even if access to interventions is limited, compassionate and kind care need not be."

Please use the following public links: 

Research: https://www.cmaj.ca/lookup/doi/10.1503/cmaj.240061

Research: https://www.cmaj.ca/lookup/doi/10.1503/cmaj.231250

Humanities: https://www.cmaj.ca/lookup/doi/10.1503/cmaj.230935

Editorial: https://www.cmaj.ca/lookup/doi/10.1503/cmaj.240878

Media contacts:

Dalhousie University: Alison Auld, Senior Research Reporter, Communications, Marketing and Creative Services, Cell: 1-902-220-0491, Email: alison.auld@dal.ca

Women's College Hospital: Maria Madden, Manager, Public Affairs, Women's College Hospital, maria.madden@wchospital.ca, 416-300-5346

University Health Network: Vicky Zeldin, Director, Strategic Communications, vicky.zeldin@uhn.ca, 416-300-5346

University of Alberta: Sarah Vernon, University of Alberta communications associate, svernon@ualberta.ca

General media contact: Kim Barnhardt, CMAJ, kim.barnhardt@cmaj.ca

Please credit CMAJ, not the Canadian Medical Association (CMA). CMAJ is an independent medical journal; views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of its owner, CMA Impact Inc., a CMA company, or CMA.